Battle of the Rose Face Mists: Herbivore, Pixi, and Trader Joe’s

I love a good rose face mist 🙂 It seems like every brand has one these days so I thought it might be helpful to compare three in my stash from Herbivore Botanicals, Pixi Beauty, and Trader Joe’s.

IMG_E0814

The Trader Joe’s option is clearly the best bang for your buck: $3.99 for 4 oz/118 mL! I like that this is in a plastic bottle, which is handy for travel, although too large for an airplane carry-on.

IMG_E0824

The full ingredients are: Water, Rosa Damascena Flower Water, Rosa Damascena Flower Oil, Witch Hazel Leaf Water, Quillaja Saponaria Bark Extract, Glycerin, Phenoxyethanol, Citronellol, Geraniol, Hexyl Cinnamal, Linalool, Fragrance.

I like that this one includes rose flower water, rose flower oil, and witch hazel, although it does include artificial fragrance. This one smells the strongest of the three. It has a really nice, even mist that sprays enough to make you feel like something happened but not so much that it would ruin your makeup. It’s pretty hard to beat this budget option!

Next up, a new addition from Pixi Beauty: Rose Glow Mist, which retails for $15 for 2.7 oz/80 mL from Pixi or Target. So although the bottles appear to be about the same size, you’re getting considerably more product from the Trader Joe’s option.

This packaging was very difficult to photograph!

IMG_E0827

The Pixi option has 7 oils in it to give you a “glow” so if you have oily skin, you may not love this one. You need to give it a good shake before you spray to redistribute everything.

The full ingredients are damn near impossible to read on the packaging but Pixi’s website has the full list: Water, Olive Fruit Oil, Glycerin, Dipropylene Glycol, Butylene Glycol, Argania Spinosa Kernel Oil, Caprylyl Glycol, 1.2-Hexanediol, Safflower Seed Oil, Betaine, Avocado Oil, Anise Fruit Extract, Trehalose, Panthenol, Eclipta Prostrata Extract, Artemisia Absinthium Extract, Arnica Montana Flower Extract, Achillea Millefollum Extract, Viola Mandshurica Flower Extract, Hibiscus Esculentus Fruit Extract, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract, Gentiana Lutea Root Extract, Pelargonium Graveolens Flower Oil, Cymbopogon Martini Oil, Melia Azadirachta Leaf Extract, Vegetable Oil, Cananga, Odorata Flower Oil, Rosa Damascena Flower Oil, Bergamot Peel Oil, Propylene Glycol, Moringa Oleifera Seed Oil, Tocopherol.

This one doesn’t particularly smell like rose, probably because there’s so much other stuff in it and the rose flower oil is at the bottom of the INCI list. It’s nourishing because of all the oils in it so I think I’ll reach for it more in the winter.

You may recall that I complained in this Empties post that the mister on the Pixi vitamin makeup mist was lousy. I’m pleased to report that the packaging on this mist is much improved and the mist sprays evenly. I don’t feel any residue the way I did with the vitamin wakeup mist, either.

Lastly, we have the Herbivore Botanicals rose hibiscus coconut water hydrating face mist, which is available loads of places including Herbivore and Sephora. This one retails for $32 for 4 oz/120 mL so it is, by far, the most expensive choice.

IMG_E0822

Herbivore is a well-known “green” beauty brand, if that’s something you’re looking for. I must admit, I love the minimalistic packaging and beautiful glass bottle. This, too, has a nice, even mist and easy to use spray. This is the “wettest” of the three mists, but I would still apply it over makeup without worrying about disrupting my makeup. I don’t necessarily find this one to be more hydrating long-term; it’s more about how it feels when I first apply it since I tend to rely on mists for a quick boost.

The full INCI list: Water, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice, Rose Damascena Flower Water, Witch Hazel Flower Water, Leucidal Radish Root Ferment Filtrate, Hibiscus Sabdariffa Flower Extract, Coconut Water, Melia Azadirachta Flower Extract, Coccinia Indica Fruit Extract (Neer Sikkappu Red)

The Herbivore ingredients are a lot like the Trader Joe’s list, and those two mists smell and feel much more similar than the Pixi option. Unless you’re a real purist about green beauty and do not want any fragrance in your products, I would suggest you save your pennies and head to Trader Joe’s (or find a friend to do it for you if you don’t live near one!).

As an added bonus, all three of these brands are cruelty free!

Let me know if you’ve given any of these a try, or if you have another rose face mist that you love! 🙂

IMG_E0816

(None of the links are affiliate links; they’re simply used for your convenience. I purchased all of these products myself.)

March Empties!

It’s that time again – March empties! Sorry I’m a little behind this month 😉 One of the reasons I started this blog was to have space to review my monthly empties, so tuck in!

thumb_IMG_E8327_1024

I will review by category. And as you know if you follow along on Instagram, this year I’ve also been tracking the value of my monthly empties. This does not mean what I paid for a specific item. Some things are part of a set, gifts with purchase, etc. which would make it very hard to determine what I actually paid. But I like having this idea of value, even if the totals can get embarrassingly high…

First up, skincare and a lone haircare product:

thumb_IMG_E8333_1024

— Good Things manuka honey cream cleanser – I raved about this recently in a #oneemptyonenewbie post. Someone on Instagram introduced me to this and I found it for about $6 at TJ Maxx. It was undervalued in my stash when we lived in southern California, but I learned the value of a soothing cream cleanser over the last several months. Between pregnancy and a Minnesota winter, my skin was dry and sensitive. This cleanser was so soothing on irritated skin. Thankfully I have two backups thanks to a kind friend 🙂 Did I mention this is $6? If you see it at TJ Maxx/Marshall’s, grab it! It’s available on Amazon but since it isn’t sold by Amazon, I, personally, wouldn’t trust it.

— Leahlani citrus + citrine toner – Both of Leah’s toners are absolutely lovely. They will transport you to a tropical paradise. Actually, all of her products do that 😉 I think I prefer the scent of the Bohemian Ruby toner, which I finished quite a while ago and, if memory serves, smelled more fruity and less floral than this one (although the names would indicate the opposite). I’ve finished a few Leahlani treats recently so I think an order is forthcoming. Value = $46

— Dr. Jart ceramidin cream – I think I tried this sample during the wrong time of year.  I had just finished a rich Zelens moisturizer, which I was mixing with a pump of marula oil, and this didn’t feel like enough. I think I would like it during warmer months, though. Maybe I’ll be able to get another sample and try again since I know a lot of people who love it. Value = $4.80

— Amika nourishing mask* – I used this in place of a regular conditioner and really enjoyed it. My hair felt silky smooth after I got out of the shower. I have several similar products to get through or I would repurchase. Value = $12

— Fresh lotus youth preserve face cream – This has a nice mid-weight and silky texture. It has the same lovely cucumber smell as the soy face cleanser. Value = $17

Next up, body care:

thumb_IMG_E8331_1024

— Lush Ro’s Argan Body Conditioner – I love this stuff. It smells incredible and feels luxuriously rich on the skin. It isn’t sufficient to protect my skin in the winter, but it helps, and I feel fancy when I use it 😉 I’m using a Hempz in-shower body conditioner at the moment and it is not the same…. Sigh. Value = $6.83

— Kiehl’s creme de corps whipped body butter in grapefruit – They aren’t kidding when they call this stuff whipped butter. It had both the color and texture of butter, which kind of weirded me out. It didn’t smell too much like grapefruit, either. I know the regular creme de corps is a cult Kiehl’s product but I didn’t much care for this. (The grapefruit scent in Disney packaging was a holiday limited edition product but I’ve linked the currently available version.) Value = $39

— L’Occitane shea foot cream – I get minis of these from time to time. They’re nice for dry winter feet, but I don’t personally believe you need a separate foot cream. Value = $2

— Caudalie divine oil – A nice, multi-purpose dry oil. It has a “more mature” scent, shall we say? But I like it. It isn’t the most moisturizing oil ever, but it’s hard to find one that is moisturizing enough alone for MN winter. Value = $7.35

— Caudalie hand and nail cream – One of my all-time fav hand creams. It’s not as thick as the L’Occitane shea butter ones (which I also love) but still moisturizing and not greasy, and it absorbs quickly. It has a refreshing slightly fruity, slightly floral scent. I don’t know what grapes smell like, but if this is it, they smell great! 😉 I wish they sold larger sizes! Value = $15

— Jo Malone blackberry and bay shower oil packet – Blackberry and bay isn’t my favorite Jo Malone scent, but the consistency of the shower oil was very luxurious. It reminded me of the L’Occitane almond shower oil – a shower staple for me. I would consider purchasing in a different scent.

Lastly, makeup:

thumb_IMG_E8336_1024

— Stila huge extreme lash mascara – One of my favorite mega volumizing mascaras. It’s hard for me to find a volumizing mascara that doesn’t smudge on my oily eye area and this is one of the few that doesn’t. I always jump at a chance to pick up a mini. This one seemed to dry out a little quickly, though. Value = $12

— Vapour Beauty illusionist concealer – The consistency was too firm to be used under the eyes, which is the primary purpose of a concealer for me. You would have to warm up the product first with your finger or else it would pull and tug when I tried to apply it. I only tried that a few times before deciding the delicate skin under my eyes was more important. It worked just fine for blemishes so I kept it in my purse in case I needed to touch up during the day, but I rarely used it. I’ll stick with non “green” concealers in the future. Value = $24

— Farmacy lip bloom in citrus lemongrass – These have been discontinued, but since they’re still available on Farmacy’s website I will warn you against them. This dried out my lips so badly. I don’t think I’ve ever experienced anything like it. After about two weeks of trying to make it work, I decided to throw in the towel. The citrus lemongrass smelled nice, though. Value = $16

— Skincando Combat Ready lip balm –  I LOVE combat ready balm. The lip balm, not so much. It was a stiffer texture and I didn’t find it very moisturizing. Value = $10

— Fresh sugar lip treatment in Rose (mini) –  I love the Fresh lip balms. They’re very soft and feel so nice on. They have lots of colors, including several everyday ones that provide just enough color. This rose shade falls into that category and seems to be the most common in gifts with purchases, gift sets, etc. I have others. I will repurchase. Value = $12

— Kevin Aucoin the celestial skin liquid illuminator sample packet in Candlelight – This gave off a nice effect as an illuminating makeup primer, but the shade Candlelight was too dark for my fair/light complexion and I believe it’s the lightest shade he makes.

— Fiona Stiles eyebrow pencil – I got this super cheap when Ulta stopped carrying Fiona Stiles’ line and I don’t believe you can buy her makeup anymore. It was pretty Meh anyway. Value = $16

— Marc Jacobs hi-shine lip lacquer (mini) in Allow Me – I’m not a big lip gloss girl, but I enjoyed this formula. It wasn’t sticky or tacky. I didn’t think it was “high shine,” despite the name. This shade had some shimmer in it, but it didn’t translate to the lips. I would explore other shades since there are lots in the range. Value = $10

— Jouer liquid highlighter – I honestly can’t really review this. It’s very old and I pulled it out recently to see if it still worked and it didn’t; it has dried up. I don’t love the click stick type packaging so I wouldn’t repurchase for that reason alone. Value = $24

 

Total value of March empties = $278.98!

Well, there we are! Thanks for getting all the way to the bottom 🙂 Have you used any of these products? If so, I’d love to know your thoughts!

*Gifted by Influenster